Revenues totaling €3,620,607, for which no valid receipts were issued, were recorded by the Tax Department as part of its investigation into the financial activities of the Holy Monastery of Saint Avvakum, according to the testimony of the head of the Tax Fraud Investigation Unit, George Georgiou, before the Nicosia Permanent Criminal Court.
This development took place during today’s continuation of the trial, with the first prosecution witness presenting in detail the findings of the tax investigation, which concerned the commissions received by the Monastery, construction work for its construction and renovation, as well as its commercial activities.
Mr. Georgiou informed the Court that a review of deposits into bank accounts for the period 2018–2024 revealed a total amount of €4,857,356.
At the same time, cash payments totaling €1,264,162 were recorded, while the receipts issued amounted to a total of €738,969.
“The calculation determines the amount of receipts for which no receipt was issued, which totals €3,620,607,” he stated.
She clarified, however, in response to a related question from the representative of the Prosecution, Theodora Papakyriakou, that the bank records were examined by the agency but were not used in the calculations that led to the tax assessment.
Tax liability: €285,067.49
During his testimony, the head of the Tax Fraud Investigation Unit stated that, according to the tax assessment letter, the Avvakoum Church owes, for the audit period from September 1, 2021, through March 31, 2024, the amount of €285,067.49, plus surcharges and interest.
As explained, the purpose of the investigation was to determine whether there were serious weaknesses or deficiencies in the maintenance of the Monastery’s accounting books and records, which would justify the rejection of the tax returns that had been filed.
Since, as noted, deficiencies and weaknesses were found in the books and tax returns, the agency proceeded to make its own calculations in order to determine the taxable income and the amounts that should have been reported.
The audit period covered the time from September 1, 2021, to March 31, 2024. The witness stated that, at the time of the audit, the Monastery had filed tax returns only for the period from September 1, 2021, to March 31, 2022, which were filed late.
After the audit was completed, all tax returns covering the entire audit period were also filed late.
When asked whether the filing of the returns affected the results of the investigation, he replied in the negative, explaining that due to the weaknesses and deficiencies identified in the accounting records, the returns were not accepted.
He added that only the revenue and sales that had already been reported were taken into account, so that they could be subtracted from the calculations of unreported sales.
“Arbitrary tax returns”
Reference was also made to how the Monastery’s tax returns were filled out, with the witness explaining what the tax authority meant by the term “arbitrary tax returns.”
As he testified, the evidence examined revealed that there was a pre-prepared spreadsheet in an Excel file specifying the amount to be reported, and the blanks were then filled in with names from a list that was also contained in the same file.
“The correct procedure would have been to record all receipts—whether they were payment receipts or sales invoices—and for that total to be the amount reported on the tax return. Instead, we observed—this was our initial conclusion—that they decided what amount to enter,” he stated.
Sales of €1.475 million from commercial activities
Referring to the Monastery’s commercial activities, Mr. Georgiou presented the calculation of expected sales from the exhibition, the pastry shop, and the Monastery’s store.
According to the data he presented, expected sales were estimated at €1,475,074, while sales reported on tax returns amounted to €243,958. The difference between the two amounts was calculated at €1,231,116.
When asked how he would characterize this particular turnover based on his experience, the witness stated that, if a classification were made based on sales volume, the Monastery could be classified as a “small-to-medium-sized enterprise.”
At the same time, for the additional sales from the showroom, the store, the delivery of ready-made products, and the pastries, the undeclared output tax was calculated at €125,450.40.
The witness explained that this particular calculation “was the largest ever made for the Monastery” and included 11 different categories, for each of which a separate methodology was followed.
Commissions from Tours and Construction Work
Regarding the commissions the Monastery received from organizing excursions, the witness stated that these involved a partnership with the company Loucas Travel and Tours, operating under the trade name Nazoreos Travel.
As he explained, according to the information obtained by the police, the company organized tours in collaboration with the Monastery, under an agreement to pay it a commission. The information included check numbers and wire transfers made to the Monastery.
The output tax attributable to these commissions, which was not reported on the tax returns, amounted to €15,974.37, the witness stated.
When asked whether commissions from organizing excursions are subject to tax, he replied that “all commissions are taxed at the standard VAT rate.”
In addition, the witness referred to an amount of €143,642.74 as output tax attributable to services received by the Monastery in connection with a civil engineering project, pursuant to Article 11B.
As he explained, the amount stemmed primarily from contractors’ invoices for the construction and renovation of the Monastery.
When asked whether monasteries are eligible for any VAT exemptions, he replied: “As far as VAT legislation is concerned, there is no exemption for any taxpayer.”
Findings Regarding the First Defendant
During the proceedings, the prosecution asked the witness whether an audit had also been conducted on the personal tax returns of the first defendant, former Archimandrite Nektarios, whose secular name is Ioannis Georgiou.
Mr. Georgiou answered in the affirmative, clarifying that the audit concerned everyone involved in the case.
“The audit covered everyone involved in the case. However, we only found evidence against the first defendant,” he said.
How the investigation began
Describing his agency’s involvement in the case, the witness stated that it began following a letter from the Cyprus Police to the Tax Commissioner, requesting that documents in the Police’s possession be examined to determine whether any tax offense had been committed.
As he testified, a team was formed to investigate the case; its members examined documents at the police offices, visited the Metropolis of Tamassos, where they located and collected additional evidence, as well as the monastery premises, where they inspected documents found in various locations.
In addition, an inspection was conducted at the pastry and bakery workshop operated by the Monastery in a neighboring village, from which copies of relevant documents were obtained.
The team also contacted the Metropolitanate’s auditor, the head of the Audit Office of the Church of Cyprus, as well as with suppliers, in order to gather information on the Monastery’s commercial activities.
The witness, who heads the Tax Fraud Investigation Unit and has been working in the Department for eight years, stated that he gave a statement to the police on November 28, 2024.
He added that on June 13, 2024, a preliminary report had been sent to the police, at the request of the investigators, in order to determine whether, at first glance, any criminal offenses had been committed in relation to tax laws.
The report containing the Unit’s findings is dated November 20, 2024, and was submitted to the Court along with the relevant tax assessment and its annexes.
The proceedings before the Nicosia Permanent Criminal Court will resume on November 30, 2026, at 9:30 a.m., with cross-examination of the witness by the defense.
It should be noted that all defendants are presumed innocent until the Court has proven their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
