weather widget icon
20.8 °C
FRIDAY
20.11.2026 18:41
Powered by:
Member of the group
Alpha Cyprus
alpha-letter
Advertisement
20.11.2026
CYPRUS POLICE
18:18

DNA on the steering wheel wasn’t enough: Woman sentenced to prison for car theft was acquitted

The court of appeals’ findings regarding the evaluation of the testimony
ALPHANEWSLIVE


The Court of Appeals overturned a woman’s two-year prison sentence for car theft, acquitting her, as it ruled that the discovery of her genetic material on the vehicle’s steering wheel was not, in and of itself, sufficient to prove that she had committed the theft. As the court noted, it had not been clarified how her DNA came to be at that specific location.

According to the Court of Appeals’ decision, which was issued on Thursday, the woman had been convicted by the Paphos District Court of stealing a car worth €3,000, which she was alleged to have committed together with another person in November 2024. The trial court had sentenced her to two years of immediate imprisonment.

The conviction was based on circumstantial evidence, with the genetic material found on the car’s steering wheel serving as a decisive factor. Specifically, a scientist from the Cyprus Institute of Neurology and Genetics (MK3) testified that the appellant was the “primary contributor” of the mixed genetic material found at that specific location—that is, that her contribution to the sample was the largest.

However, the Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court had not correctly assessed the significance of this finding. As noted in the decision, the forensic report stated that DNA tests, in most cases, cannot on their own determine either the time or the manner in which a person’s genetic material ends up on an object.

As the Court of Appeals noted, “the prosecution’s attorney did not raise any questions regarding the issue of how the genetic material came to be on MK3, nor during cross-examination by the defense counsel. Witness MK3 also made no relevant reference to this in her live testimony. In the report, the issue of how the genetic material was deposited remained unclarified.”

At the same time, he pointed out that the car had been found abandoned in a field in Kato Paphos, two days after it was stolen—a fact which, in his view, should also have been taken into account by the trial court.

“In the present case, given the aforementioned ambiguity in the testimony regarding how the appellant’s genetic material came to be on the steering wheel of the stolen vehicle, it was not beyond a reasonable doubt to conclude that the appellant committed the offense of theft and that any other reasonable conclusion would be contrary to common sense,” he added.

As he explained, the evidence presented by the prosecution left unresolved the question of how the appellant’s genetic material came to be on the vehicle.

“The appeal is granted, and the first-instance judgment convicting the defendant is overturned in its entirety,” the Court of Appeals concluded, acquitting the appellant and releasing her from the imposed sentence.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Find all Alpha News sections below

News Feed

News Feed

More