New compromise proposal for the European Union’s Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) of the European Union for the period 2028–2034 was presented on Saturday in Brussels by the President of the European Council, António Costa, proposing a total budget of 1,582.5 billion euros, at constant 2025 prices. The proposal calls for a reduction of approximately 204 billion euros at current prices, or 10% compared to the European Commission’s initial proposal, with the aim of keeping national contributions in check.
The five proposed new sources of EU own resources are estimated to generate approximately 60 billion euros annually, in combination with existing revenue sources, with the annual levy on large companies operating in the EU (CORE) remaining outside the scope of the negotiation package.
In an effort to balance the EU’s new strategic priorities with its traditional agricultural and cohesion policies, for the first time since negotiations began, the EU’s regional spending—known as cohesion policy—is being cut across the board, while subsidies to farmers remain unchanged. The proposal calls for an increase in national contributions from 0.80% to 0.82% of Gross National Income, with more funding for migration, defense, and Horizon Europe, while also preserving the Common Agricultural Policy and, to a large extent, cohesion.
“I believe this proposal is a good basis for moving toward an agreement,” said António Costa during the presentation of the negotiation package to journalists, noting that its development was based on the work of the previous presidencies of Denmark, Cyprus, and Ireland, as well as on bilateral contacts with each member state, in order to take their concerns into account and formulate a compromise for the benefit of Europe as a whole.
The President of the European Council outlined three key objectives of the proposal, speaking of a budget that lives up to the Union’s ambitions, keeping national contributions at reasonable levels, and creating a balanced mix of new own resources. “This is a budget that lives up to our ambitions,” he said, adding that European leaders have identified three strategic priorities for the next budgetary period. These involve boosting competitiveness, strengthening security and defense, and projecting Europe’s influence in the world, he said.
According to Costa’s proposal, compared to the current 2021–2027 MFF, funding for competitiveness would increase by 120%, for defense by 232%, while funding to member states for migration and border protection would double. However, the budget for Frontex is reduced from 10.5 to 6.9 billion euros in the Costa proposal, with a European official noting that the increase relative to the current MFF is sufficient. At the same time, funding for the EU’s external action is increasing by 23%. However, taking into account the Commission’s proposal for the upcoming MFF, both defense and competitiveness appear to have been reduced, and only the funds for migration remain as proposed.
Mr. Costa noted that, despite the strengthening of new priorities, the policies that connect the Union with its regions, cities, and citizens, as well as support for farmers, are being maintained. “The new fund to support the Common Agricultural Policy and Cohesion Policy will remain the largest fund in the budget,” she noted, referring to a balanced allocation between new priorities and established policies.
Specifically, the proposal allocates 898.3 billion euros for Cohesion, agriculture, rural and maritime development, and security, compared to 946.404 billion euros in the Commission’s proposal. Of this amount, the Common Agricultural Policy, fisheries, and cohesion will receive 670.9 billion euros; migration, border management, and home affairs: €40.7 billion, with a cut to home affairs compared to the Commission’s proposal, but funding for migration maintained
For Competitiveness, Prosperity, and Security, €437.7 billion is allocated, compared to €522.2 billion in the Commission’s proposal. For the European Competitiveness Fund, €301 billion is allocated, compared to €362.3 billion in the initial proposal, of which €140 billion is for Horizon Europe, compared to €89.3 billion. For Erasmus+, 34.7 billion euros, compared to 36.2 billion euros; for Defense, Space, and Military Mobility, 95.1 billion euros, compared to 131.5 billion euros. For Global Europe, the budget is 150.1 billion euros, down from 190 billion euros, and for Administration, 96.4 billion euros, down from 104.4 billion euros.
The total budget, excluding repayment of NextGenerationEU (NGEU), amounts to 1,442.1 billion euros, while including the repayment, it reaches 1,582.5 billion euros, slightly lower than the initial proposal. The President of the European Council also noted that Horizon Europe, the EU’s flagship scientific research program, will increase by 57% compared to the current MFF, while Erasmus will be boosted by 25%, providing, as he said, “a real boost to student mobility.”
In the area of climate policy, the proposal maintains the target of allocating 35% of program spending to climate and environmental actions, as “this is the sustainable way to reduce the burden on the energy bills of families and businesses,” as he noted in this regard. At the same time, for the first time, funding for affordable housing is provided for from the outset, particularly in areas facing housing shortages. There is also a target to allocate 14% of national and regional funds to European social objectives. “In short, this budget focuses on implementing the leaders’ priorities and meeting citizens’ expectations,” Mr. Costa noted.
The second key element of the proposal concerns limiting the burden on member states. Costa stated that governments’ concerns regarding the level of national contributions have been taken into account and that the proposal remains very close to the current level. “On average, national contributions will increase from 0.80% to 0.82% of Member States’ Gross National Income,” he said.
To further limit the need to increase national contributions, the proposal provides for a pool of five new sources of own resources, based on the proposals of both the European Commission and as well as those of the European Parliament, while taking into account the comments and concerns of the member states.
The five sources are digital services, with an annual contribution equivalent to 3% of net online advertising revenue, digital intermediation services and user-generated data, for companies with a turnover from digital activities of at least 50 million euros in the EU and a total global turnover exceeding 750 million euros. The proposal removes the Corporate Resource for Europe (CORE) that was included in the Commission’s earlier proposals, under which companies with a net turnover of at least 100 million euros would pay annual flat-rate contributions ranging from 100,000 to 750,000 euros, depending on the size of their turnover, regardless of whether they are European or not.
Also included is non-recycled electronic waste, with Member States contributing based on the weight of uncollected electronic waste, at a rate of 2.25 euros per kilogram, the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), with 100% of the revenue from the mechanism directed to the EU budget, tobacco products, with a contribution based on the minimum tax rates for tobacco products (TEDOR), at a rate of 15%, as well as the Emissions Trading System (ETS), with a 30% contribution on revenues from ETS 1. “Combined with existing revenue sources, these could generate approximately 60 billion euros annually,” said Mr. Costa.
To avoid placing a disproportionate burden on certain Member States, the introduction of own resources from the ETS and tobacco products is planned to be phased in. Specifically, for Member States eligible for the Modernization Fund, the ETS rate will start at zero in 2028 and gradually reach 30% by 2034. Similarly, for Member States whose share of tobacco products exceeds 150% of their share of GNI, the rate will start at 5%, increase to 10% after three years, and reach 15% by 2034.
At the same time, Mr. Costa noted that work will continue on the European Parliament’s proposal regarding a new own resource from cryptocurrencies, while the European Commission will be tasked with examining additional revenue from future radio spectrum auctions. With regard to existing own resources, changes are also planned to customs rules and to the percentage of traditional own resources retained by member states, as well as an increase in the rate for non-recycled packaging to 1.25 euros per kilogram, adjusted for inflation.
In closing, the President of the European Council described the proposal as realistic. As he noted, the total reduction of approximately 204 billion euros at current prices, compared to the Commission’s initial proposal, is intended to limit national contributions. “I believe this proposal can bring us closer to a final agreement,” he said, adding that he would continue to work with all leaders to achieve this goal.
The proposal comes just five days before the upcoming extraordinary MFF Summit on December 26–27 in Brussels.
Source: CNA
